Blog 

When it comes to caring for precious gemstones, one of the most common questions that jewelry owners ask is whether their beloved pieces can safely come into contact with water. This concern is particularly relevant for garnet and ruby jewelry, two of the most popular gemstones used in fine jewelry collections. Understanding the water resistance properties of these gemstones is essential for maintaining their beauty, durability, and value over time. In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore everything you need to know about exposing garnets and rubies to water, the safe standards for natural gemstones, and best practices for caring for your precious jewelry.

Understanding Garnet and Ruby Properties

What Are Garnets?

Garnets are a group of silicate minerals that have been treasured for thousands of years. The name "garnet" comes from the Latin word "granatum," meaning pomegranate, due to the stone's resemblance to the fruit's seeds. These gemstones are known for their deep, rich colors, with red being the most famous variety. However, garnets come in a stunning array of colors including orange, yellow, green, pink, and even color-changing varieties.

The most common type of garnet used in jewelry is the almandine garnet, which is prized for its deep red color and excellent durability. Garnets have a hardness rating of 7 to 7.5 on the Mohs hardness scale, making them relatively durable for everyday wear. They possess a refractive index that gives them excellent sparkle and brilliance, comparable to many precious gemstones.

Garnets are primarily composed of aluminum silicate minerals, and their crystal structure contributes to their physical properties. The density of garnets ranges from 3.5 to 4.3 grams per cubic centimeter, depending on the specific variety. This density makes them heavier than many other gemstones of similar size, which is one way to identify authentic garnets.

What Are Rubies?

Rubies are the red variety of the mineral corundum, the same mineral that produces sapphires in other colors. The red color in rubies comes from the presence of chromium oxide, and the intensity of this color is what determines the value of the stone. Fine rubies are among the most expensive gemstones in the world, often commanding higher prices per carat than diamonds.

Rubies have a hardness rating of 9 on the Mohs hardness scale, making them the second hardest natural gemstone after diamonds. This exceptional hardness makes rubies extremely durable and suitable for all types of jewelry, including engagement rings and daily wear pieces. The refractive index of rubies is approximately 1.76 to 1.78, which contributes to their brilliant sparkle and deep red glow.

The crystal structure of rubies is hexagonal, and they often contain natural inclusions and characteristics that are actually indicators of authenticity. Rubies are found in various locations around the world, with Burmese rubies being considered among the finest quality, followed by Thai, Vietnamese, and African rubies.

Water Exposure and Gemstone Safety

Can Garnets Get Wet?

The answer to whether garnets can get wet is nuanced. Garnets themselves are generally safe to expose to water, as they are not soluble in water and do not have cleavage planes that would make them prone to splitting when wet. However, there are several important considerations to keep in mind.

First, while the garnet stone itself can tolerate water exposure, the settings and treatments applied to the stone may not be as water-resistant. Many garnets are treated with oils or resins to enhance their appearance and fill surface fractures. These treatments can be compromised by prolonged water exposure, particularly hot water or water containing chemicals like chlorine or salt.

Second, the metal settings used in garnet jewelry, whether sterling silver, gold, or other alloys, may be affected by water exposure. Sterling silver, which is commonly used in garnet jewelry manufacturing, can tarnish when exposed to moisture and certain chemicals found in water. Gold settings are more resistant to water damage, but they can still be affected by chlorine and other harsh chemicals.

Third, repeated thermal shock from exposing garnets to hot water followed by cold water can potentially cause stress fractures in the stone. While garnets are relatively durable, they are not immune to thermal shock, and this is a consideration for those who wear garnet jewelry while bathing or swimming.

For these reasons, it's best to remove garnet jewelry before bathing, swimming, or engaging in activities where the jewelry might be exposed to water for extended periods. If your garnet jewelry does get wet, simply pat it dry with a soft cloth and allow it to air dry completely before storing it.

Can Rubies Get Wet?

Rubies are significantly more water-resistant than garnets due to their superior hardness and lack of cleavage planes. The ruby stone itself can safely be exposed to water without any risk of damage or dissolution. In fact, rubies are often cleaned with water as part of their regular maintenance routine.

However, similar to garnets, the settings and treatments applied to rubies must be considered. Some rubies are treated with oils or resins to fill surface fractures and enhance their appearance. These treatments can be compromised by water exposure, particularly if the water contains chemicals or if the ruby is exposed to hot water.

The metal settings used in ruby jewelry are also a consideration. While rubies themselves are water-resistant, the gold, silver, or platinum settings may be affected by prolonged water exposure or exposure to chlorinated water. Additionally, any gemstones set alongside the ruby, such as diamonds or other stones, may have different water resistance properties.

For optimal care, it's recommended to remove ruby jewelry before swimming, bathing, or engaging in water-intensive activities. However, occasional exposure to water during normal daily activities is generally not harmful to the ruby itself, though it may affect the setting or accompanying gemstones.

Safe Water Standards for Natural Gemstones

Understanding Gemstone Hardness

The Mohs hardness scale is the standard used to measure the hardness of gemstones and minerals. This scale ranges from 1 to 10, with 10 being the hardest. Understanding where your gemstones fall on this scale is crucial for determining their water resistance and overall durability.

Diamonds, the hardest natural gemstone, rate 10 on the Mohs scale. Rubies and sapphires, both varieties of corundum, rate 9. Garnets typically rate between 7 and 7.5. This difference in hardness is significant when it comes to water exposure and overall durability.

Gemstones with a hardness rating of 7 or above are generally considered suitable for everyday wear and can tolerate water exposure better than softer stones. However, hardness alone does not determine water resistance. Other factors, such as cleavage, fractures, and treatments, also play important roles.

Cleavage and Fracture Characteristics

Cleavage refers to the tendency of a gemstone to split along planes of weakness in its crystal structure. Some gemstones have perfect cleavage, meaning they will split easily along certain planes. Others have no cleavage at all, making them much more durable.

Garnets have no cleavage, which means they are not prone to splitting along natural planes. This is one reason why garnets are relatively durable and can tolerate water exposure better than gemstones with perfect cleavage. Rubies also have no cleavage, which contributes to their exceptional durability.

Gemstones with perfect cleavage, such as diamonds and some varieties of feldspar, are more susceptible to damage from water exposure, thermal shock, and physical impact. Water can seep into microscopic fractures and cause expansion and contraction, potentially leading to further damage.

Treatment and Enhancement Considerations

Many gemstones, including garnets and rubies, are treated or enhanced to improve their appearance. These treatments can affect the water resistance of the stone and must be considered when determining safe water exposure standards.

Common treatments for garnets include:

• Oil or resin filling to enhance color and fill surface fractures
• Heat treatment to improve color
• Irradiation to change or enhance color

Common treatments for rubies include:

• Oil or resin filling to enhance appearance
• Heat treatment to improve color and clarity
• Surface coating to enhance luster

These treatments can be compromised by water exposure, particularly if the water contains chemicals or if the stone is exposed to hot water. It's important to know what treatments have been applied to your gemstones so you can care for them appropriately.

pH and Chemical Considerations

Water itself is generally safe for most gemstones, but the chemicals dissolved in water can pose risks. Chlorine, commonly found in swimming pools and some tap water, can damage certain gemstones and their settings. Salt water, found in oceans and seas, can corrode metal settings and potentially damage some gemstones.

The pH of water can also affect gemstone safety. Acidic water can potentially damage certain gemstones over time, while alkaline water is generally safer. Most tap water is neutral to slightly alkaline, making it relatively safe for gemstone exposure.

Hard water, which contains high levels of minerals like calcium and magnesium, can leave deposits on gemstones and their settings. These deposits can dull the appearance of the stone and potentially damage the setting if not cleaned properly.

Best Practices for Garnet Jewelry Care

Daily Cleaning and Maintenance

To keep your garnet jewelry looking beautiful and well-maintained, regular cleaning is essential. For daily cleaning, use a soft cloth to gently wipe away dust and oils that accumulate on the surface of the stone. This simple step can help maintain the brilliance and sparkle of your garnets.

For more thorough cleaning, you can use lukewarm water and a mild soap solution. Create a mixture of lukewarm water and a few drops of mild dish soap. Soak your garnet jewelry in this solution for a few minutes, then gently scrub with a soft-bristled brush, paying special attention to the setting where dirt and oils can accumulate. Rinse thoroughly with clean water and pat dry with a soft cloth.

Avoid using hot water for cleaning garnets, as thermal shock can potentially cause damage. Also avoid using ultrasonic cleaners or steam cleaners, as these can be too harsh for garnets, particularly if they have been treated with oils or resins.

After cleaning, allow your garnet jewelry to air dry completely before storing it. Moisture left on the jewelry can promote tarnishing of metal settings and potentially damage the stone over time.

Storage Recommendations

Proper storage is crucial for maintaining the beauty and integrity of your garnet jewelry. Store your garnets in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Prolonged exposure to sunlight can fade the color of some garnets, particularly lighter varieties.

Keep your garnet jewelry separate from other jewelry to prevent scratching. While garnets are relatively hard, they can still be scratched by harder gemstones like diamonds or sapphires. Use individual soft pouches or compartments in a jewelry box to store each piece separately.

Avoid storing garnet jewelry in humid environments, as moisture can promote tarnishing of metal settings and potentially damage the stone. If you live in a humid climate, consider using silica gel packets in your jewelry storage area to absorb excess moisture.

Activities to Avoid

To protect your garnet jewelry, avoid wearing it during certain activities. Remove your garnets before bathing, swimming, or engaging in water sports. The combination of water, heat, and chemicals can damage both the stone and its setting.

Avoid wearing garnet jewelry while doing household chores, gardening, or engaging in sports and exercise. These activities expose your jewelry to dirt, sweat, and potential physical impact that can damage the stone and setting.

Remove your garnet jewelry before applying lotions, perfumes, or other cosmetic products. These products can leave residue on the stone and setting, dulling their appearance and potentially causing damage over time.

Best Practices for Ruby Jewelry Care

Daily Cleaning and Maintenance

Rubies are more durable than garnets and can tolerate more aggressive cleaning methods. For daily cleaning, use a soft cloth to gently wipe away dust and oils. This simple step helps maintain the brilliance of your rubies.

For more thorough cleaning, you can use lukewarm water and mild soap solution, similar to the method used for garnets. However, rubies can also tolerate slightly warmer water than garnets, though you should still avoid very hot water to prevent thermal shock.

You can use a soft-bristled brush to gently scrub the ruby and its setting, paying special attention to areas where dirt and oils accumulate. Rinse thoroughly with clean water and pat dry with a soft cloth.

Unlike garnets, rubies can generally tolerate ultrasonic cleaning, though this should be done carefully and only if the ruby has not been treated with oils or resins. If you're unsure about the treatments applied to your ruby, it's best to stick with gentle hand cleaning methods.

Professional Cleaning and Inspection

For valuable ruby jewelry, consider having it professionally cleaned and inspected periodically. Professional jewelers have specialized equipment and expertise to clean rubies thoroughly without causing damage. They can also inspect the setting for any signs of wear or damage and make repairs as needed.

Professional cleaning is particularly important for rubies that have been treated with oils or resins, as these treatments require special care and expertise to maintain properly.

Storage Recommendations

Store your ruby jewelry in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. While rubies are more color-stable than many gemstones, prolonged exposure to intense sunlight can potentially affect their color over time.

Keep your ruby jewelry separate from other jewelry to prevent scratching. While rubies are very hard, they can still be scratched by diamonds or other rubies. Use individual soft pouches or compartments in a jewelry box to store each piece separately.

Avoid storing ruby jewelry in humid environments, as moisture can promote tarnishing of metal settings. If you live in a humid climate, consider using silica gel packets in your jewelry storage area.

Activities to Avoid

While rubies are more durable than garnets, it's still best to remove them before swimming, bathing, or engaging in water sports. The combination of water, heat, and chemicals can potentially damage the setting or any accompanying gemstones.

Remove your ruby jewelry before engaging in sports, exercise, or strenuous activities. While the ruby itself is very durable, the setting can be damaged by physical impact, and the jewelry can be lost or damaged during vigorous activity.

Avoid wearing ruby jewelry while doing household chores or gardening, as exposure to dirt, chemicals, and potential physical impact can damage the setting and potentially scratch the stone.

Understanding Gemstone Treatments and Water Resistance

Oil and Resin Treatments

Many garnets and some rubies are treated with oils or resins to enhance their appearance and fill surface fractures. These treatments are common in the gemstone industry and are generally considered acceptable if properly disclosed.

Oil treatments are particularly common for garnets. The oil fills surface fractures and enhances the color and clarity of the stone. However, oil treatments can be compromised by water exposure, particularly hot water or water containing chemicals like soap or detergent.

Resin treatments are also used for both garnets and rubies. These treatments work similarly to oil treatments, filling surface fractures and enhancing appearance. Resin treatments are generally more durable than oil treatments but can still be compromised by prolonged water exposure.

If your gemstone has been treated with oil or resin, it's particularly important to avoid prolonged water exposure and to clean it gently with lukewarm water and mild soap rather than hot water or harsh chemicals.

Heat Treatment

Heat treatment is commonly used to enhance the color and clarity of both garnets and rubies. This treatment involves heating the stone to high temperatures to improve its appearance. Heat-treated stones are generally stable and not affected by water exposure.

However, heat-treated stones should still be protected from thermal shock, which can occur when a hot stone is suddenly exposed to cold water or vice versa. This is why it's best to avoid wearing heat-treated gemstone jewelry while bathing or swimming.

Irradiation Treatment

Some garnets are treated with irradiation to change or enhance their color. This treatment is stable and does not affect the water resistance of the stone. Irradiated stones can be safely exposed to water without any risk of damage.

Comparing Garnet and Ruby Water Resistance

Hardness Comparison

The primary difference between garnet and ruby water resistance is their hardness. Rubies, with a hardness of 9 on the Mohs scale, are significantly harder than garnets, which rate between 7 and 7.5. This difference in hardness means that rubies are more resistant to scratching and physical damage, which can indirectly affect water resistance.

Harder gemstones are less likely to develop microscopic fractures that can be exacerbated by water exposure and thermal shock. This makes rubies inherently more water-resistant than garnets.

Cleavage Comparison

Both garnets and rubies have no cleavage, which means they are not prone to splitting along natural planes. This is an advantage for both gemstones in terms of water resistance. Gemstones with perfect cleavage are much more susceptible to water damage, as water can seep into cleavage planes and cause expansion and contraction.

Treatment Comparison

Garnets are more commonly treated with oils or resins than rubies. These treatments can be compromised by water exposure, making treated garnets more vulnerable to water damage than treated rubies. If you have a treated garnet, it's particularly important to avoid prolonged water exposure.

Rubies are